Skip To Main Content
Skip To Main Content

College of Staten Island Athletics

COLLEGE OF STATEN ISLAND ATHLETICS

Softball Coaching Staff

 
TraceyTracey Garofalo                               
Head Coach

Years: 4
Won-Lost (Pct.): 57-115 (.331)

Phone: (718) 982-3165
Email: tracey.garofalo@csi.cuny.edu

The College of Staten Island Athletic Department has named former Post University Head Coach Tracey Garofalo as its new Softball Head Coach in the summer of 2021

Garofalo was the Head Coach of the Post University Softball Team for 15 seasons, where she helped develop an Eagles unit that improved in a host of offensive and defensive categories throughout her tenure. Garofalo's primary responsibilities included devising game strategies and scouting, along with comprehensive recruiting in-line to meet the University's academic and athletic thresholds.
 
Drawing upon her extensive coaching experience, Graolafo is eager to lead similar growth of the CSI Softball program and help usher in a return to normalcy.  Garofalo also brings with her experience in the NCAA compliance world at the Division II levels having served as Assistant Athletic Director of Academic Success at Post University alongside her coaching duties.​
 
Tracey Garofalo
Year-by-Year
Year Overall Conf.
2022 12-26 6-18
2023 11-37 3-17
2024 15-31 7-13
2025 19-21 7-13
TOTALS 57-115 23-61

CassHS24Cassidy Petrie
Assistant Coach

Cassidy Petrie joined the Softball coaching staff in 2021 Assistant Coach.  Petrie has been playing softball since the age of five and brings with a wealth of experience.  She states her biggest accomplishment as a coach would be assisting Head CoachTracey Garofalo in building the CSI Softball Program and turning it into a competitive program in Division 2 Softball.
 
“The most rewarding thing is getting to work with and develop our players’ skills and watching them succeed on and off the field,” said Petrie.  “As a student/player, my biggest accomplishments include being a four-year starter for the Post University Softball Team, as well as four successful seasons with winning records.”  
 
Petrie brings a deep familiarity of knowledge of the game that will be beneficial towards the Dolphins.

 
SantiagoSBHS_2024Robert "Coach Sugar" Santiago
Hitting Coach


Robert Santiago was hired as Hitting Coach for the CSI Softball Team in 2022.  Playing men’s open level fastpitch softball for over 30 years in numerous different states and countries, Santiago will bring valuable insight to the program. 
 
Santiago grew up playing a variety of sports including baseball, football, hockey, and basketball.  In 2019, he landed his first coaching job as an independent hitting coach for the Extreme Baseball and Softball Academy, where he is still working today. Santiago also has two National Championship awards, ASA (Amateur Softball Association,) and NSA (National Softball Association.)   In addition, he obtained a national batting title in men’s ASA fastpitch, and is among the top five teams in world championship rankings between 2012-2021. 
 
Santiago has grown as a hitting coach during his six years of experience by watching his young men and woman compete and be successful at all levels of fastpitch and baseball.  He has coached student-athletes that have played from the D3 through D1 level in Baseball and Softball, some of whom have graduated with degrees becoming doctors, nurses, lawyers, teachers, police officers, and firemen.  Most importantly, Santiago serves as a dedicated and supportive coach who always has his students best interest at heart. 
 
CoachSB24_HSDr. Coach
Therapy Dog